Re: [Harp-L] The final final final final final final word on Comb Materials



There is one possible difference for the player:
I find that metal and plastic combs produce a 'splashback' of saliva more than wooden combs, even sealed ones. Basically when you blow, then suck on the same holes, you get more saliva coming back at you. I guess the saliva adheres better to the wood. So I like the playing feel of wood more (although not enough to replace combs etc on the models I like that have plastic or metal combs). Sometimes the splashback is quite distracting. I hope the listener cannot hear me being distracted.
Richard


On 24 Dec 2008, at 16:08, David Payne wrote:


"If everyone knows the arguments, then those who claim that comb materials perceptibly affect tone must do so deliberately, disregarding both acoustic theory and empirical evidence to the contrary... I was corrected on my statement, in passing, that diatonic harps have 'Richter tuning...' I assume that newbies look to Harp-l for correct information. Should we not do our best to avoid misleading them?”

Well, yeah. I suppose I did not call you on that. The way I go about it, is I try to say “Richter note placement,” even thought that itself isn't technically accurate, but meanings of words change and when people think of Richter, they think of the note placement, not construction. Anymore, I just try to describe it that way, to set that example. In retrospect, I might have written you off list had I noticed it, because people do look up to you and respect you as they do, I do see where you feel a burden of personal accuracy.
On the other hand, I've a similar crusade of sorts about sealed wood. My chromatics do not crack, regardless of what weather changes I put them through. My diatonics do not swell from playing. There was a time when somebody said “wood combs suck. They crack, etc.” I'd chip in something about the benefits of a good sealing, but eventually I figured out that I can't change the world and I backed off and went with a more “here's how to seal wood” approach. You can't change everybody's mind, regardless of how much evidence you've got. You should check out the flat earth society forum, theflatearthsociety.org it's hilarious and, with a billion times more research and facts confirming a round earth than difference in comb materials, it serves as the ultimate example of no matter how much is out there, you can't change every mind. They invite people to come in and argue round earth, people say "how come hurricanes rotate in a different direction south
of the Equator." Ans: "It's a conspiracy." "Home come somebody can't just go to the edge of the earth and take a picture of the flat earth. This is an actual quote from the FAQ page: "The government prevents people from getting close enough to the Ice Wall to take a picture." I offer the society as an example only to illustrate how hard it is to change minds once they're made up.
As for me, I don't know. I truly do not know and don't consider it of monumental importance, just an interest. There's numerous variables at work, I notice differences in different harmonicas of the same model and construction. Why? I don't know.


“I cannot initiate a bend without constricting the air flow
at or near the mouthpiece and drawing much harder. However,
I'm not going to state that as a fact because I have only my
own subjective experience with no hard evidence or theory to
support it.
Very true and it is not fact for every diatonic. When I evaluate a harp, a main difference to be between a good custom and stock is the ability to initiate a deep bend at minimal breath, actually at the minimal amount of breath it takes for the reed to vibrate. The reason it takes a harder draw is breath is wasted, whether by an imperfect mate of comb and reedplate, or via around the reeds themselves.


________________________________
www.elkriverharmonicas.com
_______________________________________________
Harp-L is sponsored by SPAH, http://www.spah.org
Harp-L@xxxxxxxxxx
http://harp-l.org/mailman/listinfo/harp-l

Richard Hammersley Grantshouse, Scottish Borders http://www.last.fm/music/Richard+Hammersley http://www.myspace.com/rhammersley http://www.myspace.com/magpiesittingdown








This archive was generated by a fusion of Pipermail 0.09 (Mailman edition) and MHonArc 2.6.8.